Because rehabilitation is more effective
Punitive justice won’t change the way people think, the cycle will just repeat
Things like the death sentence don’t work, because people are still murdering, even though they know that they face execution for it
It’s a pointless punishment
It’s a pointless punishment
Idk, there are some pieces of shit that just need a bullet to the head. Serial killers/rapists don’t need rehabilitation. They need to be erased.
I want to preempt this by apologizing if you are a victim yourself, or at least say I don’t speak for all victims. That said, threatening violence - unless as immediate defense - is not moral within my view. I’ve been raped and had loved ones violently murdered. I would not wish pain on those responsible. I want them to understand and grow as people. Maybe it will never happen, and I can accept that. I can’t accept loosening my moral standards and sinking to their level.
Sequestering them from society is more preferable. Requiring therapy. Community service.
I’ve been in therapy off and on for years. One piece of advice a therapist gave me that I’ll never forget is to never stop being an idealist.
It doesn’t prevent crime
Because at first you have to find the cause of the behavior. Punitive justice should be the last resort. The problem, the moment justice has to work, a problem was not discovered and solved early enough. I would say every government punishment is a prove about a community and government failure. The moment justice step in you need to punish an incorrect behavior to prove that the rules that exist are valid and enforced. So one part of the punishment is not for the criminal it is for strengthen the existing rules.
In developed countries there should not only be the punishment but also an investigation how this could happen and some form of help to solve the issue. And additional punishment if other people where harmed.