• 0 Posts
  • 58 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 1st, 2023

help-circle












  • that’s just skin deep, and that’s never been a factor turning me away from media. They can be mixed even if cultures are distinct.

    yes, but I think it’s the most obvious and consistant problem for most shows. another one for example is in the case of WoT the lack of architectural styles in different culutres.

    But that feels like a symptom of deeper problems

    yeah I agree



  • Acinonyx@lemmy.sdf.orgtoA Comm for Historymemes@lemmy.worldRealism
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    6 days ago

    Yes, you can. That is literally the idea.

    fair enough. but that’s most of the time not compatible with “it has to be believable and fleshed out”. you can add PoC, but they should have their own destinct cultures, like GoT did with the Dorne or the magical city in Essos; or the Ophiri in Witcher 3. the people of Dorne were all a homogenous group of people, as is to be expected in a medieval setting where traveling is hard, the same with the Ophiri. if half of the population of Dorne was white, it’d be odd.

    It just felt… boring, and the world wasn’t interesting.

    like I said, that’s because of the worldbuiling, every group of people looked the same (except for the costumes, which were pretty bad), every architectural style looked the same, there were no distinct culural differences. the whole world is one homogenous blob. just compare it to GoT

    ATLA is another great example of diversity done right. every faction has their own unique identifiers, which make sense from a geographical point of view

    The reason for a mix of ‘PoC’ is whatever one makes.

    yes, diversity has to be done right, like in GoT or ATLA. just throwing a bunch of PoC into a random setting and calling it a day doesn’t cut it, but that’s exactly what is done most of the time and if you critisize it, you’re racist

    I’ll eventually play KCD2 if I find the time



  • Acinonyx@lemmy.sdf.orgtoA Comm for Historymemes@lemmy.worldRealism
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    edit-2
    6 days ago

    From what I’ve seen, settings are either fantasy/fiction

    you can’t put everything you want into a setting just because it’s fantasy/fictional. you wouldn’t want a BMW in your medieval setting just because it’s fantasy, it’s the same with an overrepresentation of PoC.

    or they handle the local mix of ethnicities pretty well.

    that’s almost never the case. I don’t know about KCD2, but Witcher 3 did a good job. in the wheel of time (the show) for example, every “culture” looks the same and the worldbuilding is not believable, and that’s the case for most modern media